This recipe is simple and has flavor, visual appeal and craveability.
After making this a few times, try different types of breads and cheeses.
Try adding slices of prosciutto or smoked ham or grilled vegetables.
I like to serve bitesize squares of grilled cheese as croutons to dunk into cream of tomato or cream of mushroom soup... amazing!
A Beginner’s Guide to Grilled Cheese
Grilled cheese may be thought of as one of the simplest sandwiches to make, but mastering it is a challenge. I've practiced this recipe to offer an almost foolproof recipe...
It's a cooking lesson in heat control, texture, and balance.
When I teach beginners, I start with grilled cheese because it demonstrates key cooking principles: how to properly heat a pan, how fat adds flavor and conducts heat, browning reaction, and how cheese melts.
With just a few delicious ingredients and a little attention, you can turn an everyday sandwich into something crisp, gooey, and deeply satisfying... delicious.
In this post, we’ll look at the fundamentals — choosing the right bread, selecting a good melting cheese, and cooking at the proper temperature — so even a first-time cook can create a grilled cheese worth remembering.
Grilled Cheese
Prep Time: 10 min
Cooking Time: 15 min
Yield: 1 portion
Ingredients
2 ea Bread slices (you can choose ciabatta, sourdough, etc... pick your favorite)
2 slices Cheese (American, Cheddar, Mozzarella, etc...) try using two cheeses in the same sandwich
3 Tbsp Butter, lightly salted
Step 1
Set up mise en place of the bread, cheese and butter. Place the cheese onto one slice of bread and place the second slice of bread on top to make a sandwich.
Note-you can add a slice of ham or tomato or bacon etc... if you like.
Warm a small pan (I like teflon for grilled cheese) and add butter to melt.
Step 2
Add the cheese 'sandwich' to the pan, into the melted butter. Let the bottom slice of bread absorb the butter for one minute and invert the sandwich so there is butter on both sides. Be careful, it will be warm to hot.
Note-you could butter the bread before adding to the pan but I find the bread tears too easily.
Step 3
Use a rubber spatula to flip the grilled cheese sandwich, you can peek to see how quickly the bread is browning. (it will brown in about 1 minute so peeking is advised). Carefully flip the sandwich and move the pan from the heat. The pan is hot enough to brown the other side.
Note-cook at medium heat so there is time for the cheese to melt. If you have the heat too hot, the cheese will not melt.
Step 4
Split the sandwich and enjoy.
Chef Tom's Cooking Class Minute: Week 3 Cooking Pork Spare Ribs
Years ago I traveled around the south for a few weeks researching some of the amazing foods of each region. In Charleston, I was introduced to a local pig farmer, Tank Jackson who manages Holy City Hogs. Tank and his wife raise heritage breed pigs and distribute the pigs around the country. He offers on-site cooking whole pig roasts, primal cuts and sausages, and I believe he produces the best pork in the country.
Years ago, while working as a chef in a busy continental restaurant, we featured grilled, fresh swordfish on the menu—finished with a generous spoonful of herbed compound butter and capers. It was popular and delicious. One afternoon, a seafood purveyor stopped by with a sample of frozen swordfish steaks, fully thawed and ready for evaluation. Curious, we grilled it side by side with the “fresh” swordfish we had been serving—fish we believed to be of high quality. The result was surprising. The frozen swordfish was superior—firmer, cleaner in flavor, and more consistent in texture. In contrast, our “fresh” fish, likely several days out of the water, lacked the same integrity. It was a defining moment and an important reminder: in many cases, properly handled and quickly frozen seafood can offer better quality than fish labeled as fresh. For chefs, understanding sourcing and handling is just as critical as technique—especially with a product as prized as swordfish.
Chef Tom's Cooking Class Minute: Week 2 Cooking Rice: creating socarrat—
Chef Tom's Cooking Class Minute: Week 1 The Biggest Mistake People Make When Cooking Scallops
The name "caponata" itself has a fascinating origin story. One popular theory suggests it derives from capone, the Sicilian word for mahi-mahi. Historically, wealthy Sicilian aristocrats enjoyed a sweet-and-sour fish dish. Because seafood was too expensive for the working class, local home cooks substituted fish with affordable, meaty eggplant. Over time, this creative peasant food evolved into the beloved antipasto we celebrate today, often rounded out with celery, olives, and capers.
From Talk to Action: A Chef’s Challenge for School Lunches
The legendary New York-style cheesecake was famously popularized by Lindy’s Restaurant , an iconic Theater District deli opened in 1921 by German-immigrant Leo "Lindy" Lindemann and his wife Clara . A NY-style cheesecake has a dense but velvety cream cheese base, citrus zest, and a distinct cookie-dough pastry crus t. For years, I took the bus into NYC to work in amazing restaurant kitchens. On one bus ride I met and became friends with a manager at the legendary Lindy’s Restaurant. One day, he did the ultimate honor: he shared the closely guarded, original cheesecake recipe with me. This new recipe is directly inspired by that legendary Lindy’s classic, capturing its iconic velvety richness and signature flavor profile, but re-engineered for a modern, protein-packed lifestyle. Why This Recipe Delivers High-protein swap : Cottage cheese provides a clean, protein-packed base that replaces heavy fats without sacrificing richness. Silky texture : Blending the batter thoroughly ensures a velvety smooth consistency that rivals any NY-style cake. Savory-approved : Simple, foolproof assembly that requires no pastry-chef precision to get a perfect bake every time.
One of the great pleasures of my career is spending time each year working as a Culinary Educator aboard a cruise ship alongside my wife. She teaches baking & pastry while I focus on savory cooking and culinary techniques. Our travels take us to fascinating ports around the world, providing opportunities to explore local markets and study regional cuisines. I have a particular affection for the Mediterranean and always make it a point to seek out local variations of pesto, one of the world's great culinary treasures. One evening aboard ship, the pasta station served rigatoni with a choice of pesto, marinara, or Alfredo sauce. The cook prepared each order by reheating the pasta in hot water and then finishing it briefly in a sauté pan with the selected sauce. I watched in disbelief as he prepared to heat the pesto exactly the same way. "Horror!" flashed through my mind. Pesto is not a cooked sauce. Heating it aggressively dulls the fresh basil aroma, darkens its vibrant color, and diminishes the delicate flavors of basil, garlic, pine nuts, and extra virgin olive oil that make pesto so special. I may have startled the cook when I quickly called out, "Please don't cook my pesto!" Instead, I asked him to simply toss the hot rigatoni with the pesto off the heat, allowing the warmth of the pasta to gently release the fragrance and flavor of the basil. The result was exactly as pesto was intended to be enjoyed—fresh, vibrant, aromatic, and unmistakably Mediterranean.
As chefs, we spend years mastering sauté work. I remember my early days working the sauté station for lunch in a French restaurant in NYC. We served over one hundred guests in an hour-and the food was excellent — a dozen hot pans on the flat top, stocks simmering, mise en place of freshly chopped herbs, minced shallots, butter for mounting into sauces à la minute. There is rhythm to good sauté cooking. You learn quickly that great sauté work is not about rushing — it is about organization and control .